What Can Burgers, Crinkle Fries, and Great Shakes Teach Us About Employee Ownership? Quite a Lot, It Turns Out.

Topic: 
Ownership Culture
Authors: 
Kathleen McInerney Kane
Graphic of President Kathleen McInerney Kane along with an image of the book cover "What Could Possibly Go Right" by Danny Meyer with the text "book review"

I picked up Danny Meyer’s recently published book What Could Possibly Go Right? with more than casual interest. Danny is a family friend, and I’ve been a frequent guest at several of the Union Square Hospitality Group’s restaurants, my favorite being Gramercy Tavern in autumn.  I’ve long admired the Union Square Hospitality Group (USHG), not simply for the restaurants themselves, but for Danny’s pioneering approach to hospitality that has helped reimagine dining. Of all the restaurants in the group, the one that best captures the extraordinary scale of that pioneering spirit of reimagination is Shake Shack. What began in 2001 as a humble hot dog cart in Madison Square Park, created to support a public art project, became a permanent kiosk in 2004, and ultimately a publicly traded company with hundreds of locations around the world.  

What particularly drew me to Danny’s book was its subtitle, The Essential Journey to Scale an Enduring Culture. I am currently the President of Praxis Consulting Group, a consulting firm that works extensively with employee-owned companies in 3 areas: Leadership, Strategy, and Culture. The promise of employee ownership is fundamentally long-term. Creating lasting value for employee-owners requires organizations to grow, adapt, and change, while also stewarding what is distinctive and worth preserving. Much of our work lives in that tension:  How do you grow a business without losing what made it special?

A restaurant can replicate a recipe. A company can duplicate a manufacturing process, acquire complementary or adjacent businesses, expand its service offering, purchase state-of-the-art equipment, and hire more people. The much harder thing to replicate is the experience people have of the organization: how decisions get made, how customers are treated, how colleagues treat one another, what happens when someone makes a mistake, and whether people feel genuinely responsible for the whole company rather than simply their individual area.

This is culture. And culture does not scale automatically just because the business does.  

For those of us who work with employee-owned companies, this idea has particular resonance. Employee ownership is, legally, about who owns the shares. But its real potential is realized only when people begin to behave like owners: seeing beyond their own function, understanding how the business works, speaking up when they see a problem, taking initiative, sharing information, and recognizing the connection between what they do every day and the long-term health of the enterprise.

One of my favorite ideas in the book is right in its title.  Leaders are well practiced at managing risk, so they habitually ask: "What Could Possibly Go Wrong?" Danny flips the question to "What Could Possibly Go Right?" and, in doing so, introduces the concept of Practical Optimism.

Practical Optimism is not naïve optimism; it’s the discipline of acknowledging risk while not letting risk become the organizing principle for leadership.

While reading about the concept of Practical Optimism articulated in the book, I found myself translating the ideas into questions that USHG may have asked regarding Shake Shack, and questions we encounter every day in our work with employee-owned companies.  

For Shake Shack:

  • What if expanding the menu doesn't distract from what Shake Shack does best, but gives guests even more reasons to love it?
  • What if adding something that isn't a burger, fry, or shake brings an entirely new guest to Shake Shack?
  • What if experimenting with the menu teaches us something about what our guests want that we never would have learned by playing it safe

For Employee-Owned Companies:  

  • What if this acquisition delivers the value we imagine, and more, for our business and our employee-owners?
  • What if moving beyond the product that has long defined our brand creates the opportunity to redefine our business?
  • What if the person we thought was not quite ready turns out to be exactly the leader the organization needs for what comes next?
  • What would we do differently if we were able to “see” these optimistic outcomes?

‍

‍Change Your Grip

For all of you golfers and tennis players out there, another concept that stayed with me is the invitation to “Change Your Grip.” The leadership approach that created yesterday’s success may become the thing constraining tomorrow’s growth.

  • Providing all the answers may work until the company becomes too big or more complex.
  • Making the important decisions yourself may work until scale requires dozens of people capable of exercising judgment.
  • Holding the knowledge yourself may work until the organization needs that knowledge embedded in people, systems, and culture.

That may be one of the book’s most important lessons for Founders (who often need to loosen their grip), and leaders of employee-owned businesses need to understand what the future may require of them, and how they need to change their grip in response.  

And that brings me back to those burgers, fries, and shakes. The lesson learned from Shake Shack’s journey is not that there is a formula for scaling a great company; it is that growth asks something of us. It asks us to imagine what could go right, to loosen our grip on what worked yesterday, and to trust other people with what comes next. For employee-owned companies, the stakes are even higher because we are not simply building businesses for today's leaders or today's employees. We are building them for people we may never meet. Perhaps that is the ultimate promise of employee ownership: to leave the company stronger, more capable, and more valuable than we found it, and to make sure the next generation of employee-owners knows it is theirs to do the same.

‍

AttachmentVisit Link

Other Articles by: 

Kathleen McInerney Kane

What Senior Leadership Teams Can Learn from Cheetahs

A distinctive physical feature helps cheetahs move with precision at high speeds. What can this teach us about leadership?

Read More
Be Prepared: Make a Succession Plan

Succession planning is most successful when it works at the system level to develop leaders.

Read More
Webinar: Study the Past, Create the Future: How to Build a Successful Leadership Succession System

Learn how to implement an effective succession system, including who to involve in the process and how and when to start thinking about leadership succession.

Read More
Webinar: Inspiring Accountability in Employee Owners at All Levels

How can you inspire employee-owners to feel accountable towards each other?

Read More
Webinar: Facilitating Responsible Leadership Succession in Employee Owned Companies

Kathleen McInerney Kane and David Paul, CEO of Aqua Engineering, discuss how to approach succession planning.

Read More
Strategies of Successful Leadership Teams

Learn six strategies to strengthen a leadership team in complex, dynamic environments.

Read More